Dear AoIR Community,
I’m writing to share two new reports containing original research on the information environment surrounding US data centers from the Communication Technology Research Lab (CTRL) at Pitt.
The
first paper explores industry-led pro-data center propaganda and astroturfing campaigns. The
second looks at how communities and activists across the country are using novel technological strategies to respond.
The field work portion of this research included several months on the ground across eight states. We did 25 interviews with community leaders, activists, and others working against data center development across 21 primary sites. Some participants’ additional
experiences in nearby data center fights represented a total of approximately 36 sites.
Key findings:
-The data center industry — a large, decentralized, but often coordinated combination of Fortune 500 tech companies, real estate developers, equipment suppliers, and service vendors like construction firms — works actively to shape public discourse (both on-
and offline) about its business through information control measures like covert messaging, front groups, astroturfing, online and offline propaganda, and, occasionally, mal- and disinformation. (Paper One)
-Despite wide-ranging informational challenges and a diverse array of opponents, all of the community leaders and activists we spoke to built and leveraged a strikingly similar set channels, which we call the activism communication technology stack (ACTS):
Turnout, Money, Own Media, Press, Drafting, The Record, Core Group, Network, and Legal. (Paper two)
The reports were co-written by a collaborative team with expertise across social science, public health, economic development, policy research, and (of course) internet studies: Samantha Totoni, Maia Woluchem (also of Data & Society), Dean Jackson (also of
Tech Policy Press), and I. I’d like to extend a huge thanks to my co-authors!
Both papers, and other recent work from the lab and our collaborators, can be found here:
https://pittctrl.org/
I hope you find the findings useful. Happy to chat about them any time.
Best,
Sam