Hi Emmanuel,
Thank you for raising this on the AoIR list. I’m a researcher in information systems, and part of my work focuses on digital accessibility and how accessibility policies are implemented in practice. I’d be interested in exploring a short article with you.
Smartphone-dependent verification can create real barriers, and many of the individual steps have workable alternatives. For example, when a service needs to deliver a one-time code, an automated voice call can read it aloud, including on a landline. When verification requires a camera, accessible instructions and real-time spoken feedback can help users position their face or an identity document. Recent advances in AI could make that feedback more precise, for example by telling users which way to move a document or alerting them to glare.
These options address different barriers. A voice call can make a code available without a smartphone, while better camera guidance can make a camera-based process easier to complete. Where a service requires a smartphone camera, a separate verification route would still matter for people who cannot or choose not to use one.
I’d be interested in looking at a few concrete examples together and asking which alternatives are available, who can use them independently, and where providers could offer more choice. If that fits what you had in mind, I’d be happy to talk.
Best regards,

נכתב על ידי E. S. Gray via Air-L, ב־13/11/2026 בשעה 02:33:
Hi AOIR folks,
I was wondering if there was anyone doing research on tech giant reliance on smart phone/mobile technology to provide access to their services, and resulting inequalities in access to their services/software/technology.

For example, many entities are using identity verification processes which require use with a smart phone/mobile access to a browser or app (and do not provide equivalent processes for use with a regular computer/PC). Others have two-step verification methods that also rely on access to mobile or pricey authenticators.

In terms of access, it can feel increasingly restricting when you do not have a smart phone for reasons to do with economic resources, disability/health, ethical concerns, or privacy concerns.

Without a smart phone you cannot access Signal or WhatsApp, you cannot complete verification on several popular social media sites (e.g., LinkedIn, Meta), and you cannot access technologies you would otherwise be eligible for when starting a small business, non-profit, or building a movement (e.g., anything reliant on Goodstack).

This seems like it would impact how much people can build visibility and communication around themselves and their work, amplifying digital and accessibility inequalities, and undermining free and conscientious consumer choice.

I am wondering if anyone is writing about this, or if there was some brief, op-ed, or call-to-action type of publication I could support. I don't know how these matters get elevated, but I was thinking, it would be good to bring more attention to this, especially as more and more people are switching away from smart phone personal use - often for non-negotiable reasons. My background and experience are more on the side of disability justice and health (psychology), perhaps there's someone working in ethics and/or privacy who would want to pair up for a well-rounded article? Or someone else in health or disability for a more focused article?

best,
Emmanuel

National Coalition of Independent Scholars (NCIS)
Community Psychology & Critical Communication
grayea.scholar@gmail.com
LinkedIn

_______________________________________________
The To unsubscribe send an email to air-l-leave@lists.aoir.org mailing list
is provided by the Association of Internet Researchers http://aoir.org
Subscribe, change options or unsubscribe at: 
Join the Association of Internet Researchers: 
http://www.aoir.org/
--
Dr. Harel Chait
Strategy Advisor | AI, Digital Transformation & Accessibility
Harel@Chait.info | +972 54 449 3937 | LinkedIn | X (Twitter)