To be consequent you have to ban all other internet sources too. And all the magazines that are peer reviewed too, because lately they made some major mistakes too. Yes i am polemic. You correctly say that: It is as easy to change an article for the worse as for the better. Well why didn't Mr Siegenthaler change it to the better by himself? He used all the power of old media (and he is very powerful) to discredit new media. And you are jumping on the bandwagon, as if the credibility concerns are something new. But apparently it takes the power of the New York Times... This is a different discussion.
If enough of us prohibit Wikipedia as a reference source in our courses, programs, and schools, the message will eventually get through. And by the way, what is the message that will eventually get through? Trust no one except your teacher???
I suggest its better to discuss the problem with the students than to simply ban a source. Personally I think using Wikipedia as the only source, as it is with any single source, is bad scientific style. And this problem can not be solved by prohibiting Wikipedia. But maybe I understand the teachers job wrong. Best regards, peter
-----Original Message----- From: air-l-bounces@listserv.aoir.org [mailto:air-l-bounces@listserv.aoir.org] On Behalf Of Ken Friedman Sent: Sonntag, 04. Dezember 2005 20:02 To: air-l@aoir.org Subject: [Air-l] Wikipedia warning -- Wikipedia is not a reliable information source
Dear Colleagues,
This letter is a suggestion that you address the problem of bad information in student papers from an increasingly poor source: Wikipedia. Wikipedia is not getting better. It is getting worse. One reason for this is the apparent case that the status of Wikipedia as a much-used reference resource makes it the target of opportunity for hoax efforts that would never enter an edited reference text.
There are now enough serious incidents of false and defamatory information in Wikipedia biographies to warrant prohibiting this as a reference source in universities and university-level professional schools. The same is true of inaccurate or false assertions in many articles.
The problem with Wikipedia is not that the Wiki system MAY develop a solid and reliable reference work, but that in the current form, it DOES NOT. It is as easy to change an article for the worse as for the better.
Nearly any university student today has access to a decent library and good on-line reference texts. In addition, anyone willing to search a bit will also fine outstanding SIGNED references sources by major scholars in many fields, as well as useful albeit older versions of respected references source no longer covered by copyright.
The current scandal concerning a false and defamatory biography of Robert Kennedy aide and friend John Siegenthaler (see below) and similar recent cases lead me to conclude that Wikipedia has no way to prevent problems like this from happening. This is made worse by the fact that Wikipedia is an automatic flow-through resource for other on-line sources.
Wikipedia is unacceptable as a research tool.
I have informed my students that they may no longer use Wikipedia as a reference or source on papers in my courses. I urge you to consider a similar statement. While Wikipedia may be a useful first step in seeking information, I no longer accept it as a credible source. Therefore, I advise students to look further when a project requires a reliable source.
Use of Wikipedia by students and researchers is an important validation mechanism for Wikipedia.
If enough of us prohibit Wikipedia as a reference source in our courses, programs, and schools, the message will eventually get through.
When it does, Wikipedia will find an appropriate way to monitor contributions. If they do not, the reputation of Wikipedia will sink to that of another crank web site.
Yours,
Ken Friedman
The Siegenthaler case in the New York Times and USA Today via Yahoo:
http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/04/weekinreview/04seelye.html
http://news.yahoo.com/s/usatoday/20051130/cm_usatoday/afalsewi kipediabiography
--
Ken Friedman Professor of Leadership and Strategic Design Institute for Communication, Culture, and Language Norwegian School of Management
Design Research Center Denmark's Design School
email: ken.friedman@bi.no _______________________________________________ The air-l@listserv.aoir.org mailing list is provided by the Association of Internet Researchers http://aoir.org Subscribe, change options or unsubscribe at: http://listserv.aoir.org/listinfo.cgi/air-l-aoir.org
Join the Association of Internet Researchers: http://www.aoir.org/