- Air-L - lists.aoir.org

Re: [Air-L] user generated content, motivation to post (Zeynep Tufekci & others)
by Seda Guerses 03 Feb '10

03 Feb '10

with respect to why people/users generate content, it might be fun to look at how this topic was addressed in the pre-web2.0 and pre- ecommerce times. "cooking pot markets" for example was a concept explored by rishab ghosh which first appeared in 1996, in the years following many variations were reprinted and many conferences in europe picked up on the topic (the wizards of os conference (berlin) is one example where ghosh himself was a speaker). ghosh's own homepage provides the following listing of the article: Ghosh, Rishab Aiyer, 1998, Cooking-pot Markets: an economic model for the trade in free goods and services on the Internet, First Monday, vol 3, issue 3, translated into French and German and reproduced in multiple versions in several books, journals and other publications and with respect to anonymity: we have been informally discussing a similar topic, but from the perspective of those who design, research and develop anonymizers e.g., tor. we were asking the question if anonymity leads to less successful file sharing systems in comparison to file sharing systems with a identified participants, social network or community behind it (or maybe it is for other reasons that these systems do not pick up? but this could be one aspect). i believe though that this is a different concept of anonymity then what was meant by zeynep and others. if i would try to explain the difference from a technical point of view it would look likethis: when we say "anonymity", we are not referring to the use of pseudonyms (e.g., people using nick names) or the posting of contributions without an explicit logged in user under a pseudonym called "anonymous". rather, we are talking about certain tools which in addition to the use of such pseudonyms hide the ip address of the user/ source of information. now, it would be interesting to find out what for users count as anonymous? or, what was actually meant in the earlier contributions with anonymity? and, in any case, thank you for all the other references, very useful for the discussions we have been trying to have.... :) best, s. Disclaimer: http://www.kuleuven.be/cwis/email_disclaimer.htm

1 0

user generated content, motivation to post
by nathan jurgenson 03 Feb '10

03 Feb '10

i think the "reinforce their existence as subjects" argument has precedent. try looking at Sunden's point that, online, individuals "type themselves into being" (3). danah boyd has stressed this point when discussing social networking sites. the argument might indeed follow for other online content creation, such as product reviews. boyd quotes an 18 year old stating “If you’re not on MySpace, you don’t exist” (119). in the same paper boyd states that “there is an ethos that if it is possible to access a public expression, one should have the right to do so” (138). seems very relevant. boyd, danah. “Why Youth [heart] Social Network Sites: The Role of Networked Publics in Teenage Social Life." Youth, Identity, and Digital Media. Edited by David Buckingham. The John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation Series on Digital Media and Learning. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2008. 119–142. Sundén, J. 2003. Material virtualities: approaching online textual embodiment. Peter Lang Pub Inc. nathan jurgenson graduate student dept of sociology u of maryland ------------------- Hi, A Mater student of one of my colleagues is researching about people's motivation to post, to share comments and evaluations about products and services, and about the social function of such activities. His hypothesis is that people augment their reality by being read and listened, that this activity would reinforce their existence as a subjects. He's looking for references and concepts about these questions. I would be grateful if you could help. Thank you very much, All the best Amparo Lasén Dpto Sociología I Facultad de Ciencias Políticas y Sociología UCM Campus de Somosaguas Pozuelo de Alarcón 28223 0034913942899 alasen at cps.ucm.es <http://listserv.aoir.org/listinfo.cgi/air-l-aoir.org> Sunden (2003) argues that in order to exist online, we must write ourselves into being. As the online dimension becomes more important, writing becomes central to existence in general. “If you’re not on MySpace, you don’t exist”, boyd (2008) quotes an 18 year old. Boyd (2008) discusses how SNS are sites where youth can write themselves and their communities into being. Boyd also states that “there is an ethos that if it is possible to access a public expression, one should have the right to do so” (138).

1 0

Re: [Air-L] user generated content, motivation to post
by Murray Turoff 03 Feb '10

03 Feb '10

The rather old concept of human "exchange theory" which roxanne wrote up in "the network nation" was very good at expressing participation in discussion threads where when one wrote something the fact that they got replies encouraged them to contribute more comments. Exchange theory would also state that the reward of gaining status as an expert for the contributions made to dealing with problems would also be a coin of exchange. In networks of collaborative groups it is clear that a contribution will get payback based upon the number of other collaborators. We also found when in those days we could measure the time a person spent in a single conference or a message list that they would tend to sign on often enough to get like seven +- two new items. The more active the discussion the more frequent they would sign on. when there was much less they would wait to sign on for longer periods and this lead to the observation of critical mass needed to keep a discussion going. Also at some point information overload sets in when they cannot sign in often enough to keep up with the flow. This was in the paper that roxanne and i did some years back for cacm (i think 1981) on "information overload." In delphi one of the most important motivations to get professionals to participate is to make sure they know they are going to be collaborating with a peer group where they may get more feedback of useful information than they will have to put in. Sometimes we let participants know who is in the group even if it is anonymous with respect to entries. That is I feel a good motivation for professional message lists and when one starts getting too many requests for information verses contributions of information or too many announcements of paper requests i tend to lesson my activity in the message list. i did a study a year back on information seeking behavior of professionals in emergency management and as a result, i published recently through springer a paper on a recommender system design for communities of practice based upon some of the above areas including Delphi design. i can send it to anyone interested. The original study for NLM (on my website) was not allowed to incorporate any solutions to the information seeking behavior problems of emergency management professionals. But if you read the 60 page raw appendix of their actual text answers to our open ended questions the solutions become clear and in the paper i later published. The original inquiry was a one round delphi on information seeking behavior and problems using a snowball sampling and open ended text questions in a word file we sent people. By the way people who make comments but never get replies tend to stop making comments. Distinguished Professor Emeritus Information Systems, NJIT homepage: http://is.njit.edu/turoff

1 0

altruism, giving to the crowd
by Barry Wellman 02 Feb '10

02 Feb '10

Concur with denise about reputation building as a motivator for contributing, but not the whole story: -- giving to the collective whole: many of us have worked to build AoIR, for example. Wikipedia another great example -- desire to set the record straight. Every time I see some pundit say that social isolation is increasing, grrrrr I'm sure there are other things too. Barry Wellman _______________________________________________________________________ S.D. Clark Professor of Sociology, FRSC NetLab Director Department of Sociology 725 Spadina Avenue, Room 388 University of Toronto Toronto Canada M5S 2J4 twitter:barrywellman http://www.chass.utoronto.ca/~wellman fax:+1-416-978-3963 Updating history: http://chass.utoronto.ca/oldnew/cybertimes.php _______________________________________________________________________

1 0

Mobi21 FREE Webinar > Mobile Learning In The Real World > February 18 2010 > 1-2 PM EST
by gerrymck 02 Feb '10

02 Feb '10

[1] Mobile Learning Fundamentals: Innovation Showcase and Real-World Examples / Presented by A.J. Ripin / With Special Guest > Dr. David Metcalf The way that we live, work, play, and learn is being impacted by the increasing mobility of our global society. As leaders, it is our responsibility to design for the needs of our changing audience. Learn the key trends and technologies that are fast emerging to meet the challenges and changes of today and tomorrow. Come hear this conversation as we explore advanced concepts like mobile performance support, compliance, games and simulations, location awareness, transcoding, mobile social networking and collaboration. Learn firsthand how world leaders from industry, academia, military and organizations like Google, Microsoft, Tyco International, Tufts University and others are delivering value through Mobile Learning content. [2] Mind Over Technology – The Value Of Content Design In Mobile Education / Presented by Supra Manohar / EVP Emantras The discussion of mobility in education has primarily focused on technology and devices. It is critical to understand that the maturation of the market is driving the need for understanding content design and why it is probably one of the most critical aspects of any mobile learning initiative. Understanding how we learn in specific environments is critical to learning design. Using online content without pedagogical modifications within mobile environments probably does not work. The primary thrust of mobile education must be the design of the content and utilization of technology to deliver this content. This presentation will explore learning design for mobile environments and critical factors that need to be considered for a successful initiative (relative to content). Links To Source / Registration / Etc Available At [ http://tinyurl.com/yhx5sff ] EnJOY !!! /Gerry Gerry McKiernan Associate Professor Science and Technology Librarian Iowa State University Library Ames IA 50011 Follow Me On Twitter > http://twitter.com/GMcKBlogs >>> "The Future Is Mobile" >>>

1 0

WWW2010 Conference and CoLocated Conferences Open for Early Registration
by paul jones 02 Feb '10

02 Feb '10

Early registration has begun for WWW2010 through Feb 18. You can also register for 3 collocated events--WebScience, Web4Access and FutureWeb http://www2010.org/www/2010/01/registration-open/ Please distribute widely as appropriate (Thanks, Paul) And I enclose the Developers Track CfP as well. > WWW2010 - April 26 - 30 in Raleigh, NC > > WWW2010 Developers Track - Call For Proposals http://www2010.org > Submission Details > > Submission deadline: February 26, 2010 (9pm Eastern (US) Time) > > Notification date: March 14th, 2010 > > The Developers Track focuses on the general WWW development community. > Participants are invited to present new trends and interesting ideas, code > and APIs of applications, platforms and emerging standards. Demonstrations > of technical "nitty-gritty" are strongly encouraged. Focus areas include, > but are not limited to, Browsers and Plugins, Web Metrics, Health, Science > and Education, Web Social Impact, Information Integration and Mash-ups, Web > Software and Tools, Information Mining and Reporting, Mobile Web, > Monetization, Multimedia, Scalable System and Cloud Computing, Search, > Security, Semantic Web, Social Network, Standards and Protocols, User > Interface, Open Source (FLOSS) Development for the Web. > > This track is an ideal venue for short reports of both industry and > academic technical works. > > This year, the proceedings of the Developers Track will be published > online; the authors of the accepted works will have the option to publish a > 3-page report. > > Please submit abstracts and papers via the WWW2010 Conference Management > site: https://cmt.research.microsoft.com/WWW2010/Default.aspx

1 0

Call for Chapter Proposal--Social Media Campaigns: Methods and Issues
by Sarina Chen 02 Feb '10

02 Feb '10

Call for Chapter Proposal—Submission Deadline March 1, 2010 For the Edited Collection Social Media Campaigns: Methods and Issues Edited by Jayne Witte, Gayle Pohl, Tom Hall, and Shing-Ling S. Chen, University of Northern Iowa To be published by Peter Lang Publishing OVERVIEW OF THIS EDITED COLLECTION With the emergence of social media (Facebook, MySpace, Twitter, etc.), practitioners are no longer limited to traditional means of campaign methods. Social media provide campaign practitioners new opportunities to construct a new kind of campaign that is more efficient and complex than what was previously possible using traditional approaches. With new methods of contact and dissemination, practitioners are able to construct integrated social networks and implement well-coordinated campaigns. Social networking environments thus call for a different methodological orientation on the part of the campaign practitioners. This different approach begets a myriad of methods and issues not generally addressed in existing texts, except perhaps in passing. Social Media Campaigns: Methods and Issues is a collection of essays by veteran social media campaign practitioners who provide: (1) testimonial illustrations as to how to effectively utilize various online social networking tools to implement campaigns, that is, the “dos” and “don'ts” of social media campaigns, may they be political or non-political, commercial or non-profit campaigns, and (2) discussions of critical issues encountered in social media campaigns. The former serves as a resource for teachers, students and practitioners who utilize online social networking tools for campaigning. The latter is designed to stimulate ongoing debates and creative ideas about a pioneering arena of research. In sum, the book is designed to make a distinctive contribution to the literature that addresses online research, as well as the fields of inquiry for traditional campaign methods (public relations, advertising, marketing, communication, journalism, sociology, psychology, education, medicine as well as related disciplines). The book is designed to be a required textbook for campaign methods classes, as well as a resource for practitioners, as it deals with methodological considerations in developing social media campaign. PROPOSAL SUBMISSION PROCEDURE Prospective authors are invited to submit chapter proposal of 200 – 500 words on or before March 1, 2010. In the proposal, please clearly specify: (1) the purpose and content of the proposed chapter, and (2) how the proposed chapter relates to the overall objectives of the book. Authors will be notified the status of their proposal by April 1, 2010. Please send inquiries or submit material electronically to Jayne Witte at jayne.witte(a)uni.edu.

1 0

Mobile Journalism and Development
by Paulo Nuno Vicente 02 Feb '10

02 Feb '10

Hello everyone, I would like to share with you all my new research weblog - www.dev-mojo.com- on Mobile Journalism in Developing Countries. Please feel free to visit it and share your comments, suggestions, recommendations, etc. New synergies and collaboration are deeply welcome! Why not make it a collective weblog? Completely open to your ideas. Best regards, Paulo Nuno Vicente journalist | documentarist | phd student www.pnvicente.com/chaodepapel/ http://dev-mojo.com/ +351 962056247

1 0

Migrants and their use of Online Technology.
by EWB ICT4D Programs 02 Feb '10

02 Feb '10

Dear List Participants, This is a query to determine if you are aware of research studies that investigate the how's and why's of the migrant and / or diaspora usage of online technologies and social media (facebook, discussion lists, twitter, etc.,) ? Many thanks in advance, Sriram Reddy --- PhD Candidate, Faculty of Information Technology, Monash University

11 10

Re: [Air-L] Male Health
by Denise N. Rall 02 Feb '10

02 Feb '10

Denise - I would be inclined to take your email seriously if you included the institution you are affiliated with, or your supervisor, and how your topic is related to the field of internet research, and what (if any) academic use this research is designed for. (another) Denise (with no interest in this particular topic) Denise N. Rall, PhD. Special Projects, Faculty of Arts & Science, Southern Cross University, Lismore NSW 2480 AUSTRALIA Mobile +(61) (0)438 233 344 http://www.scu.edu.au/schools/esm/staff/pages/drall/ Join the Association of Internet Researchers http://aoir.org IR 11.0 Meets: 21-23 October 2010, U. of Gothenburg-Gothenburg,Sweden __________________________________________________________________________________ Yahoo!7: Catch-up on your favourite Channel 7 TV shows easily, legally, and for free at PLUS7. www.tv.yahoo.com.au/plus7

1 0